Tuesday, December 14, 2004 AD
Christmas vs Saturnalia
IntolerantElle raises a common objection to Christmas, namely that it is not really a "Christian" festival, but is instead merely a pagan festival covered with a thin Christian veneer. (This objection is in fact raised by both Christians and non-Christians - I've just spent some of the past half hour having a [light-hearted] discussion about this with some colleagues at work.)
I have two difficulties with this argument (quite apart from loving Christmas in all its aspects, which makes me a bit unsympathetic to "bah humbugs"). Firstly, I fail to see what relevance the "pagan roots" of Christmas have to the question of how we as Christians should celebrate Christmas. It's a bit like saying that you shouldn't visit your local parish church just because (in England) many ancient parish churches were founded on former pagan worship sites, so that the local church "is really" a pagan worship site (actually, in all too many cases these days, that may not be all that far from the truth. But I digress ;->).
Whatever Christmas may have started out as - whatever pagan elements, both ancient and modern, may still remain as part of the event - that cannot override entirely the vast wealth of Christian music, iconography and practice that have given Christmas an ineradicably Christian nature over more than 1500 years.
But the second objection to the "Christmas is just a rebranded pagan festival" argument is that it quite possibly isn't even true. It seems there is a strong case for arguing that the situation is precisely the reverse of what is generally assumed: that in fact the pagan festival of "the Unconquered Sun" was a hijacking of a popular Christian festival, rather than vice versa.
The case for this is put forward by William Tighe in an article from the Touchstone Magazine archives, Calculating Christmas:
Eastern Christians, on the other hand, used a calculation that made 6 April the date of the crucifixion. Add nine months and this gives you 6 January, the Feast of the Epiphany, which in the Eastern calendar is a far more significant festival than Christmas.
The point is not that these calculations were based on valid reasoning, or gave an accurate date for the birth of Christ (as Tighe points out, 25 December is "wholly unlikely to have been the actual date of Christ's birth"). The point is simply that second century Latin Christians had come to regard 25 December as the date of Christ's birth. This is in contrast to the generally-held assumption that they adopted a pre-existing pagan festival as an exercise in seeker-friendly re-branding.
As Tighe concludes:
I have two difficulties with this argument (quite apart from loving Christmas in all its aspects, which makes me a bit unsympathetic to "bah humbugs"). Firstly, I fail to see what relevance the "pagan roots" of Christmas have to the question of how we as Christians should celebrate Christmas. It's a bit like saying that you shouldn't visit your local parish church just because (in England) many ancient parish churches were founded on former pagan worship sites, so that the local church "is really" a pagan worship site (actually, in all too many cases these days, that may not be all that far from the truth. But I digress ;->).
Whatever Christmas may have started out as - whatever pagan elements, both ancient and modern, may still remain as part of the event - that cannot override entirely the vast wealth of Christian music, iconography and practice that have given Christmas an ineradicably Christian nature over more than 1500 years.
But the second objection to the "Christmas is just a rebranded pagan festival" argument is that it quite possibly isn't even true. It seems there is a strong case for arguing that the situation is precisely the reverse of what is generally assumed: that in fact the pagan festival of "the Unconquered Sun" was a hijacking of a popular Christian festival, rather than vice versa.
The case for this is put forward by William Tighe in an article from the Touchstone Magazine archives, Calculating Christmas:
Many Christians think that Christians celebrate Christ's birth on December 25th because the church fathers appropriated the date of a pagan festival. Almost no one minds, except for a few groups on the fringes of American Evangelicalism, who seem to think that this makes Christmas itself a pagan festival. But it is perhaps interesting to know that the choice of December 25th is the result of attempts among the earliest Christians to figure out the date of Jesus' birth based on calendrical calculations that had nothing to do with pagan festivals.Early Latin Christians concluded that Christ had died on 25 March 29. Based on the concept of the "integral age" – the theory that the great prophets of Israel died on the same dates as their birth or conception – they concluded that Jesus had been conceived on 25 March. Hence this became the Feast of the Annunciation, and December 25 was Epiphany.
Rather, the pagan festival of the "Birth of the Unconquered Son" instituted by the Roman Emperor Aurelian on 25 December 274, was almost certainly an attempt to create a pagan alternative to a date that was already of some significance to Roman Christians. Thus the "pagan origins of Christmas" is a myth without historical substance.
Eastern Christians, on the other hand, used a calculation that made 6 April the date of the crucifixion. Add nine months and this gives you 6 January, the Feast of the Epiphany, which in the Eastern calendar is a far more significant festival than Christmas.
The point is not that these calculations were based on valid reasoning, or gave an accurate date for the birth of Christ (as Tighe points out, 25 December is "wholly unlikely to have been the actual date of Christ's birth"). The point is simply that second century Latin Christians had come to regard 25 December as the date of Christ's birth. This is in contrast to the generally-held assumption that they adopted a pre-existing pagan festival as an exercise in seeker-friendly re-branding.
As Tighe concludes:
The pagan feast which the Emperor Aurelian instituted on that date in the year 274 was not only an effort to use the winter solstice to make a political statement, but also almost certainly an attempt to give a pagan significance to a date already of importance to Roman Christians. The Christians, in turn, could at a later date re-appropriate the pagan "Birth of the Unconquered Sun" to refer, on the occasion of the birth of Christ, to the rising of the "Sun of Salvation" or the "Sun of Justice."That said, I do dislike the "reason for the season" line which Elle refers to: not because it is inaccurate, but because it is irritating and trite. From mystery and awe ("the Word became flesh, and dwelt among us, and we have seen His glory, the glory as of the only Son of the Father, full of grace and truth") to grating advertising slogans: more evidence of how some evangelicals are making a complete hash of Christmas these days (see previous post).



